
Doing modern math: Does H5N1 = 0157:H7?
By Chuck Jolley
We’re talking worldwide impact here. The ability of one set of
letters and numbers that looks like it might be just another
algebra equation to equal another set of letters and numbers
that have already proven they’ve got staying power.
If you’ve been anywhere near the news in the past decade-and-a-half,
you know what 0157:H7 is. It’s the deeply dreaded E. coli virus
that’s deadly to small children and old folks. It was responsible
for the deaths of just a few but its effect on the beef business
was enormous.
It can be eliminated by the judicious application of heat. Cook
that burger until it’s medium, preferably medium-well done and
the problem is gone.
Now H5N1 is another matter. It’s bird flu, a disease that was
once the rare and exclusive domain of chickens. In Southeast
Asia, it has become a common disease among poultry flocks and
it has taken a frightening leap to humans. So far, it’s been
rare but staggeringly deadly and human-to-human transfer has
reportedly happened only once. Reports from Viet Nam indicate
about a 75% fatality rate once it infects a person, an
unacceptably high number, especially if it starts to become
pandemic.
The problem is conditions on rural Southeast Asian farms are
often unsanitary with poultry packed beak-by-jowl with other
kinds of livestock. The World Health Organization warns these
conditions are ripe for the development of a pandemic that
could kill millions if the virus mutates into a form capable of
easily spreading among humans.
Last year, Thailand was the center of the AI outbreak. Thai
officials acted quickly and essentially depopulated the country’s
poultry population, a drastic campaign that was supposed to stop
the spread of a disease that hit nine Asian countries.
The mass culling of birds, however, did not stop the spreading
virus.
Farmers quickly restocked without changing their habits. Poultry,
pigs and fish are still grown side-by-side as a poverty-stricken
rural population struggles to make a living. Making matters worse,
the Thai government’s agricultural officials, seriously
understaffed, lack the manpower to enforce proper animal handling
practices.
To stop the spread of the disease among flocks, farmers can require
that workers disinfect shoes, change clothing and spray their trucks
and carts before entering a poultry farm. They can also ban
outsiders from sheds, keep species segregated and keep egg trays
and cages clean. Easy enough, but not often done by most of the
undermanned, primitive Southeast Asian farming operations.
What will happen if the virus makes the jump to the human population?
WHO officials say at least 2 million and maybe as many as 7 million
people would die worldwide and those are their most optimistic
numbers. In a less cautiously optimistic frame of mind, they say
the toll could reach 100 million, a frightening number made possible
by the ease of modern travel and its concurrent and “uncheckable”
ability to spread disease quickly. The Spanish flu pandemic of 1918,
when transportation was much more limited, killed 40 million people
in just over one year.
Taking it very seriously, Tommy Thompson, former U.S. secretary of
heath and human services, said the potential death toll of a
fast-spreading avian flu was his greatest health fear. He called it
a "really huge bomb" during his farewell speech, a comment that drew
some flak from people who thought he went too far with a gloom and
doom scenario. I don’t think he went far enough. The potential
threat is still generally unacknowledged by most worldwide health
officials and the media.
In a comment to a Washington Post reporter, Michael Osterholm,
director of the Center for Infectious Disease Research and Policy
at the University of Minnesota, said, "It's clear that Southeast
Asia poses the greatest risk today of a new virus unfolding and
coming forward as a pandemic strain. Darwin could not have created
a more efficient re-assortment laboratory if he tried."
Osterholm, recognized as one of the best minds in the business, was
referring to the rural farms that are virtual fecal soup-driven
bacteriological laboratories in the area – thousands of animals of
various species grown side-by-side under unsanitary conditions in
a hot, humid environment. The odds that a relatively mild bacteria
or virus could mutate and explode with deadly international
consequences are unacceptably high.
Doing the math, the potential of A.I. to become lethal on a worldwide
scope is more than just H5N1 = 0157:H7. The death toll could explode
geometrically and it could happen very quickly. Right now, the
governments of the southeast Asian countries where the problem exists
are ill-equipped to stop the spread of the disease among their
rapidly expanding flocks. The governments and health organizations
around the world are just as ill-equipped to stop the disease if it
makes the jump to the human population.
It’s past time that the threat was met head on. If the West
continues to look toward underdeveloped Asian countries as a
resource for cheap food, immediate steps must be taken to bring
their agricultural practices into the twenty-first century. And
the bill for this must be paid by the more developed North American
and European countries.
The agrarian population and available agricultural land in developed
countries has been greatly reduced in the past 50 years. Even
with major advances in productivity, the need for enough active
farmland to feed our growing populations will soon outstrip supply.
In the coming decade, Asia will become the new American West, a
land filled with vast farms and ranches, supplying grain and
protein to the world. We must make sure the supply is safe.
Add Your Comments Here
back to top
Chuck Jolley is a marketing executive who's been associated with the food industry for over 25 years. He's helped
develop advertising and public relations programs for Cryovac, the world's largest flexible packaging company, and published
MEAT&POULTRY, the leading trade magazine in the meat and poultry industry. He's worked with major companies in the meat,
poultry, seafood, baking, dairy and fresh produce industries.Contact: crjolley@msn.com
|